My Sugar Pie

Place an Order
Place an Order

NOW OPEN- My Sugar Pie location!

Please stop by 40 East Pine Street, Zionsville and enjoy a slice or take home a whole pie to share with friends and family.

Pie Shop Hours of Operation:
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed
Tuesday 10am-6pm
Wednesday 10am-6pm
Thursday 10am-6pm
Friday 10am-6pm
Saturday 7am-3pm

The 'My Sugar Pie' pie list includes more than 40 different pies--all handmade, with a light, crispy crust that is from owner Kelly Maucere's mother's original recipe. My Sugar Pie is now available by the slice at St. Elmo Steak House in Indianapolis and Harry & Izzy's downtown and northside locations. Of course, you can still get a slice at the Cobblestone Grill in Zionsville.

Please install Flash® and turn on Javascript.

My Sugar Pie will be featured in the November 28th, 2013 issue!

“Pity the folks who have only sampled rhubarb as strawberry's costar--then send them a slice from My Sugar Pie.” - Oprah's blog

CountryLiving Magazine named our Sugar Cream Pie one of The Best Mail-Order Pies in the United States.




My Sugar Pie Gift Certificates are perfect for any occasion!