Happy Birthday, My Sugar Pie!

My Sugar Pie is in its third year! Since January 2008, My Sugar Pie has made over 3500 pies, and continues to ship pies across the United States. We grew over 65% in our second year. Thank you My Sugar Pie customers!

Located in historic Zionsville, Indiana, ‘My Sugar Pie,’ provides a variety of fresh homemade pies. The ‘My Sugar Pie’ pie list includes over 34 different pies--all handmade, with a light, crispy crust that is from owner Kelly Maucere’s mother’s original recipe. Customers have described these Midwestern works of culinary art as “decadent,” “rich,” and “yummy.”

Kelly looks forward to making your favorite pie! Shipping is now available via USPS Priority 2-3 day delivery. Please click here for more information.

Go Green with My Sugar Pie

Anchor Hocking has been selling high quality glass pie plates for over 100 years. We only use these plates because they are recyclable, produce a high-quality crust, and overall healthy, better-tasting pie. When you buy a pie locally or if we ship to you, the pie arrives in one of these wonderful pie plates. You can recycle this glass plate by returning it to My Sugar Pie for $1.00 off your next pie order!